Ten years after keratoplasty: read the differences carefully
Editorial review: not recorded.
Bottom line
In a 74-eye retrospective Hong Kong cohort, estimated 10-year graft survival was 63.8% after DSEK/DSAEK and 43.5% after penetrating keratoplasty (P = 0.15). Graft ulcers were reported in 4.9% versus 21.2% of eyes (P = 0.033).
What they did
- Design
- Retrospective cohort
- Sample
- 74 eyes; 65 patients
- Population
- Fuchs endothelial dystrophy or pseudophakic bullous keratopathy in Hong Kong
- Comparator
- 41 DSEK/DSAEK eyes versus 33 penetrating keratoplasty eyes
- Follow-up
- Mean 95 months; outcomes reported to 10 years
- Primary endpoint
- Not reported in the available source record.
What they found
Estimated graft survival at 10 years was 63.8% after DSEK/DSAEK versus 43.5% after penetrating keratoplasty (P = 0.15). At five years the observed visual acuity differed, but that association weakened after adjustment for preoperative acuity and was absent at ten years. Graft ulcers were less frequent after DSEK/DSAEK (4.9% vs 21.2%; P = 0.033).
Why read it
The long follow-up is informative, but the survival comparison was not statistically significant and baseline differences limit a direct procedural comparison.
What this does not prove
Retrospective, non-randomised cohort with small, imbalanced subgroups and historical DSEK/DSAEK techniques. The five-year visual difference weakened after adjustment; this study does not establish superiority or describe contemporary DMEK.
Numbers worth remembering
- Eyes / patients
- 74 / 65 ↗
- 10-year graft survival, DSEK/DSAEK vs PKP
- 63.8% vs 43.5% ↗
- Graft ulcers, DSEK/DSAEK vs PKP
- 4.9% vs 21.2% ↗
Original source
Source date: 11 Sept 2026 · Hong Kong
Report a correction →